The following is a letter to the editor I sent to the Rushville Republican regarding the mosque at Ground Zero issue. Yes, you’re missing the original column I’m referencing, but I think you’ll get the gist.
Dear Mr. Barada,
I am a regular reader of your column and wish to thank you for sharing your thoughts and opinions with the Rushville Republican. I have even used an article of yours in a communications class I teach at IUPUC inColumbus. I have always found your arguments and opinions to be well reasoned and thought out, but I must take issue with your column from September 28 regarding the Muslim mosque being built near “Ground Zero.”
While I realize that I am in a very tiny minority in this community, I believe that we should openly support the building of this mosque rather than opposing it. We should be lending a hand rather than throwing up roadblocks, no matter how repugnant that idea may be to us personally. Here are some of the many reasons why I disagree with your opinion:
- You don’t fight intolerance with intolerance any more than you fight economic irresponsibility with more economic irresponsibility or drug abuse with more drug abuse or crime with more crime. Mr. Gingrich says we should be intolerant because that’s how they act inSaudi Arabiabut this isAMERICA! Since when do we lower ourselves down to the lowest common denominator? We should be raising others up, not stooping to their level. We’re Americans. We’re better than that. Or, at least, the signers of the Constitution were better than that. (Yes, I’m playing the Constitution card. It can’t be helped.) Please, Mr. Barada, don’t use your voice to encourage people to take the low road. There’s enough of that going around without any need for encouragement. That sounds more like a politician than a statesman. Politicians echo what others want to hear, regardless of how low. Statesmen stand up and have the to courage to say, “You’re wrong” even when that sentiment is unpopular.
- Far too many men and women have died in theMiddle East. My question is why? We like to think they’re over there fighting to preserve our American way of life, but tell me, what is that? Did they die just to bring us cheaper oil? If so, that’s not a fair exchange. Did they die trying to kill as many Muslims as possible in order to reduce the number of future extreme radical terrorists? If so, that’s amoral. Or did they die fighting for freedom, religious tolerance, democracy, the right to free speech, etc? If so, that’s more of a fair exchange. Yes? No? Discuss.
- As a Catholic who attended parochial school and even taught middle-school aged religious education classes, I believe we should remember the simple principle of “What would Jesus Do?”. I try to apply that concept when things get tough as I can’t think of any better yard stick. While you and I will never know in this lifetime, I think Jesus would say something along the lines of, “let them come and build a house of worship in honor of my Father. By doing so, you show them the true loving heart of a Christian and you bring them closer to me which is the goal.” I could be wrong about that, but I doubt Jesus would have said, “Shove your mosque up your ass.” Obviously many others in this country believe otherwise.
- It’s my understanding that the majority of people who use this mosque won’t be radical extremists commuting in once a week from Iraq for services, but rather, will be Muslims living in New York, many of whom happen to have been born in America and were just as traumatized by the events of 9/11 as Catholic, Protestant, Methodist, atheists and wiccan American’s were. Many of these Muslims are the kind of people we want to encourage – open minded, modern thinking people rather than burka clad radicals standing in the back alleys ofBagdad. They’re the kind of Muslims we should be embracing, not turning our backs on. I can’t help but feel for the children inNew Yorkwho happen to be Muslim and who now feel like they’re somehow tainted and responsible for what happened on 9/11. It’s not right and it’s not fair to burden them with the guilt of those radicals. And can one blame them if they become defensive? Every religion, every culture, every country, every community has its radicals. You can’t right off entire religions, countries, communities, etc. because of the radical few. And I realize you’re not writing off Muslims, but just saying, “Don’t build the mosque there.” But that’s a beginning, and hatred always starts somewhere.
- What is the mosque free zone around the twin towers site? What about the existing mosque that’s four blocks away? What about the bars and strip clubs within two blocks of the site? It’s ok to have those, but not another house of worship? And does this mean that we’ll now have Catholic church free zones around playgrounds and parks (since every Catholic priest must be a pedophile)? And no Mormon churches anywhere near singles bars (since all Mormons must practice polygamy)? Tell me, what IS the acceptable distance and why? IS there an acceptable distance?
- Yes, it is extremely insensitive to build it so close to Ground Zero. I really do understand that and appreciate that. But since when do we deny people their rights for being insensitive? If that’s the case, Tony Stewart, NASCAR, the Comedy Channel and the WWF are in serious trouble.
- I am for the mosque being built near Ground Zero because I am against bigotry and prejudice in any way, shape or form. Small injustices now are the acorns of hate that grow into entire forests of hatred – hatred that leads to such things as Nazi concentration camps, Japanese interment camps, KKK rallies, etc. Those things don’t arise overnight, but grow out of years of fear and hatred and prejudice. That kind of hatred has to start somewhere. You mentioned World War II andPearl Harborin your article. The Japanese government attackedAmerica, but we went to war against the Japanese in general. That is why so many Japanese Americans ended up in internment camps in our own country during that war. Are we not sowing hatred against Muslims Americans in the very same manner?
- Regarding that hatred, please remember that Hitler ordered the Jews exterminated, but it took a whole lot of scared, silent, common everyday Germans with jobs and families and children and grandchildren to actually throw the switches on the gas chambers and kill those people. In our lifetimes there has been so much genocide – Bosnia/Serbia, the Hittus in Africa, Jews, Japanese, the Japanese trying to exterminate the Chinese, the Chinese trying to exterminateTibet. Doesn’t it get to you at all? There should be no room in our hearts for this kind of hatred. Isn’t it enough just to hate Mondays and taxes?
- I understand that what is driving this hatred in this country is fear. Before 9/11, so many Americans could pretend that this country was immune from war and terrorism and insecurity, etc. and as long as you didn’t leave its borders, you were safe. But there’s no such thing as outright safety, and 9/11 took that mistaken belief away from so many people. It shook people like my mother to their core and a part of them will never truly feel safe again. Now these same scared people want to take something from those who hurt us. They want retribution and even revenge. But that sense of security will never return, no matter how many mosques we deny the Muslims or how many countries we invade. It was never really there to begin with.
- The irony is that more people inRushCounty, inIndianaand in theUnited Stateshave been more directly hurt by the actions of our neighborhood mortgage brokers rather than any Muslim – American, African, Middle Eastern or otherwise. Keeping in this vein, it’s fairly insensitive to build a new bank with a lending department anywhere near a house that’s been foreclosed, don’t you think? I suggest you do a poll in downtown Rushville and gauge the truth of this statement. Tally up the injuries done to our neighbors by Muslims. Now tally up the injuries done to those very same people by the mortgage-backed economic downturn.
- I’m reminded of the adage that it’s a recession when it happens to my neighbor, but it’s a depression when it happens to me. In America, if something bad happens on our soil, we act like the world is coming to an end because we are an individualistic culture that believes what happens to us matters more than what happens to others. It’s a sense of self preservation. But when bad things happen overseas, we certainly whip out our checkbooks (something I applaud), but we never really seem to take it quite to heart in the same way. More Africans have died at the hands of tribal war than died in Americaas the result of terrorism. Yet we want the world to feel our 9/11 pain with us. We want to have one giant pity party and we expect the world to feel sorry for us, but so much of the world is just too darn busy trying to find food and shelter and health care and education and even running water, for heaven’s sake.
- Last but not least, I have read that some opponents to the mosque say we should be opposed to it because the Muslim faith is an extreme religion that doesn’t recognize women as equals. In that same vein, should I be worried about my Amish neighbors? Or is their faith politically correct because they can’t bring down a skyscraper with a horse drawn carriage and their subjugated women make such darn good bread? I had the good fortune to make friends with many people of the Muslim faith while working on my MBA inIndiana, and I found them to be enlightened, educated people who wanted the best for their spouses and children, regardless of age, sex, etc. I found them to be open minded, curious, warm, funny, etc. I can’t imagine looking them in the face and telling them to take their house of worship somewhere else.
In September 2000, I attended a bond management seminar in theWorldTraderCenterand I stayed at the Millennium Hotel/Marriott World Trade Center. I shopped in the basement shopping mall, visited the observation deck, attended the seminar on the 34th floor of Tower Two, looked out the windows of the Windows of the World restaurant, had a drink with friends in the bar, and laugh along with the nice young man who checked me into the Towers because his favorite movie was Hoosiers. He wanted to know ifIndianawas really like that and I told him about the old former high school in Milroy that my children were attending. I told him about our cats, chickens, rabbits and horses. We talked about my Amish neighbors and how the fields really do look like that in the morning when the sun is burning off the fog. He was captivated by it all. The memory of him still haunts me as a year later I would wonder if he were alive or dead. I simply don’t know.
In 1997 my brother, a state trooper, was killed in the line of duty. In 1998 I went to National Police week ceremonies and met an NYPD detective who had lost his partner that same year. We talked about his job and how he commuted to his work downtown by ferry and how he loved it and couldn’t imagine living anywhere else or doing anything else. Three years later I would wonder if he were alive or dead. I simply don’t know.
The attack on the Towers was personal to all of us. But we have to let this anger go.
Mr. Barada, please rethink your stance on this issue. Don’t give in to spite and fear and anger and insensitivity. Freedom isn’t acknowledging someone’s right to raise the flag, bur recognizing someone’s right to burn it, no matter how repugnant and hateful that action is. Building that mosque there should leave a terrible taste in everyone’s mouth, but build it we should. Because THAT is what makes this country great. Let’s not lower ourselves to the rest of the world’s standards. Too much is at stake.

Recent Comments